convore.json/groups/hacker-news/which-design-is-better-and-why/messages.json

[{"user_id": 23468, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300949794.134496, "message": "Could you explain why? I plan to make 2 better with details. The main issue is some found that \"there are more bars on this site than a chinese prison\"....for the first version...which I had to agree with.", "group_id": 95, "id": 424482}, {"user_id": 23468, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300949234.157552, "message": "Just finished a \"potential\" redesign thanks to some quality convore feedback. http://www.pubbsoft.com vs the new one at http://www.pubbsoft.com/fixedwidth/", "group_id": 95, "id": 424468}, {"user_id": 24472, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300949664.24245, "message": "1111111111111111111111", "group_id": 95, "id": 424475}, {"user_id": 1775, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300949702.2624819, "message": "1, without a doubt, as far as aesthetics go.", "group_id": 95, "id": 424477}, {"user_id": 13853, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300957121.475322, "message": "1 for sure", "group_id": 95, "id": 425055}, {"user_id": 8668, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300957676.956593, "message": "But you asked which is better, I'm going to choose #1 because of the curvy corners on #2", "group_id": 95, "id": 425128}, {"user_id": 13853, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300957211.8758349, "message": "all is too rounded..", "group_id": 95, "id": 425071}, {"user_id": 8668, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300957571.358501, "message": "I'm not gonna lie, neither of them is very nice, and they're quite similar... they have a lot more in common than they have differences, the biggest issues I have with the original are still present in the \"redesign\"", "group_id": 95, "id": 425118}, {"user_id": 896, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300966980.7809041, "message": "they are almost similar in terms of placement of components. wide layout looks good as far as focus is concerned.", "group_id": 95, "id": 425726}, {"user_id": 9271, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300973331.2199719, "message": "In #2 the corners with a large radius and bevel make elements look childlike. Try reducing the corner radius to 3-5px and reduce the bevel depth to 1px. I prefer #1 - the full width background looks open and expansive, while #2 looks cramped and confined.", "group_id": 95, "id": 426564}, {"user_id": 5584, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300973807.1430309, "message": "#1", "group_id": 95, "id": 426631}, {"user_id": 4375, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300975656.18503, "message": "I'm going to go ahead and say #1 just like everyone else and add that I think the idea for the app is pretty cool as well.", "group_id": 95, "id": 426834}, {"user_id": 9271, "stars": [{"date_created": 1300977569.8237071, "user_id": 13372}, {"date_created": 1301006384.9390149, "user_id": 24776}], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300974778.6434729, "message": "OK, more: I find the logo font extremely irritating. Doesn't look professional to me. Also the ellipsis at the end of your tag line makes it sounds wishy-washy or uncertain about what it says. But on the whole it's an OK design and usable but you've got a long way to go until it's jaw-dropping.", "group_id": 95, "id": 426755}, {"user_id": 9271, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300974816.9563601, "message": "i.e. hire a designer to polish it off for you, if you can afford it.", "group_id": 95, "id": 426761}, {"user_id": 9271, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300975735.44385, "message": "Sorry, I'm very picky about these things for a living - it's quite nice and you've done a great many things well.", "group_id": 95, "id": 426843}, {"user_id": 24604, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300977860.911659, "message": "#1. It just feels much cleaner. I think #2 has too much of a \"template\" feel to it.", "group_id": 95, "id": 427309}, {"user_id": 23468, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1300988114.3505659, "message": "Thanks all. Sound like #1 is the main consensus. Maybe I'll keep a more polished version of 2 around for some a/b testing.", "group_id": 95, "id": 428982}, {"user_id": 115, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1301004047.7664759, "message": "I like #2, but really the difference between these is very small compared to the difference you'll get with a better logo and colors", "group_id": 95, "id": 431566}, {"user_id": 24848, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1301007186.479686, "message": "#1 . colors are hideous tho", "group_id": 95, "id": 432271}, {"user_id": 24811, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1301007578.5202229, "message": "agree with corners being too rounded.  Also I think some work needs to be done on the color choice / button outlining, etc.  go look at your favorite bay-area startup and see how they achieve simplicity in design.  airbnb.com flowtown.com massivehealth.com etc. all good examples", "group_id": 95, "id": 432364}, {"user_id": 323, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1301010032.1556821, "message": "If you can afford it, we loved what http://www.ryanfosterdesign.com/ did for AdGrok.", "group_id": 95, "id": 432711}, {"user_id": 25120, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1301156998.8591399, "message": "I like the color scheme better in #2, but the lack of content is probably throwing people off...", "group_id": 95, "id": 446439}, {"user_id": 22988, "stars": [], "topic_id": 14910, "date_created": 1301174116.8348, "message": "First is better, you have some sick colors there but still is better than second version which is too raw at the moment.", "group_id": 95, "id": 447701}]